GNOME-3 desktop virtualization support from GNOME Boxes (and the future for virt-manager)

Posted: November 22nd, 2011 | Author: | Filed under: Fedora, libvirt, Virt Tools | Tags: , , , , , , | 4 Comments »

For many years now, the virt-manager application has been the primary open source tool for managing virtual machines under libvirt for Fedora/Linux hosts, attempting to satisfy both server and desktop users alike, with the result that often neither userbase were really too happy. The decision to use libvirt as the foundation of OpenStack, OpenNebula and various other cloud projects has been a great validation of libvirt’s capabilities. More recently, the open sourcing of the RHEV-M product to create the oVirt community project, has seen another step forward for open source data center virtualization management based upon libvirt. Finally, with today’s very first release of GNOME Boxes, the same step forward is also happening for Linux desktop virtualization. No longer will desktop virtualization (or remote desktop access) feel like an afterthought, but rather it will be a seamless part of the GNOME-3 desktop experience. This is coming to a Fedora release near you soon….the target is Fedora 17.

What does this mean for virt-manager you might wonder ? Well first of all let me reassure people that virt-manager isn’t going away anytime in the forseeable future. There will always be people who prefer straightforward, directly controllable applications which do not try to impose clever policies on their usage. virt-manager, virsh, virt-install, etc all fill this gap and we don’t want to take that control away from people. With the growth in usage of OpenStack for cloud, oVirt for data center management, and GNOME Boxes for desktop virtualization, I think it is clear though, that virt-manager will have a diminished role / userbase in the future. I don’t consider this to be bad thing, on the contrary, it shows just how strong & diverse the open source virtualization community has become. Where once there was only virt-manager, today we have a wide choice of applications providing highly effective virtualization solutions targeted towards the needs of their respective userbases.


Paul W. Frields said at 7:19 pm on November 22nd, 2011:

While I’ve long loved virt-manager, I am really looking forward to seeing an elegant, simple to use integral solution to virtualization management that fits into the rest of my GNOME 3 desktop. The fact that libvirt makes it possible to deliver so many different solutions including Boxes is an excellent reminder of libvirt’s many strengths and capabilities.

Kevin Kofler said at 4:15 pm on November 23rd, 2011:

Yet another GNOME-only solution. :-(

Geez said at 4:42 pm on November 24th, 2011:

Can’t wait to try the new oVirt.
I’ve got high expectation for the web interface; I enjoy virsh for the control but never got into the virt-manager client(struggle for my colleagues on Mac OSX for instance).
Always nice to have a web interface with different types of views for admins and management(read-only), and no worries if their corporate laptops are running another OS.

Frederik Hertzum said at 11:07 am on November 25th, 2011:

“Kevin Kofler said at 4:15 pm on November 23rd, 2011:

Yet another GNOME-only solution. :-(”

Gnome developers produce gnome solutions; it’s not like no-one can port it to another desktop or implement something similar; if there was no difference between desktops, there would only be -one- desktop.

Leave a Reply

Spam protection: Sum of thr33 plus s3ven ?: